Home » Knowledge Hub » » Q&A: Leadership – It’s All HR’s Fault

Q&A: Leadership – It’s All HR’s Fault

13 March 2024

Q&A it's all HR fault

Following on from the hugely popular Cezanne-sponsored webinar It’s All HR’s Fault, held by The HR World last week, our panellists tackle some questions left by viewers which we didn’t have time to address. Amanda Rajkumar, Jordan Barry-Bayliss and Steve Carpenter give further thoughts.


1: Do you feel that qualifications (CIPD and/or others) are required these days?

Amanda Rajkumar: Most industry professions have a corresponding qualification and I think this is largely lacking in the HR world. In the past, the CIPD was the boiler plate qualification and in the absence of anything new I think it can provide useful technical aspects and foundational level knowledge. I have worked with many HR leaders, some with it and more without with very little to tell them apart. For me, credibility in HR is more to experience, aptitude, working across different sectors and geographies and in transforming & growth companies.

Jordan Barry-Bayliss: I think the best organisations will always be focused on the academic capabilities of their recruits, across all disciplines (including HR). Demonstrable intellectual horsepower will be of critical importance for those seeking senior HR roles/a role on the c-suite, particularly if they wish to have credibility.

Unfortunately, I think the CIPD is perceived by many as old fashioned and out of step in equipping HR leaders with the basic commercial skills like figures, P&L ownership, etc.

As a CPO, the best talent I have recruited has been those with more specialst/commercially focused degrees such as psychology, economics, business and MBAs; not a CIPD. Years of vocational experience is also more important to me although, I appreciate that more traditional HR leaders, will expect some sort of CIPD qualification. I don’t.

Whilst I don’t personally have a CIPD, I do have a strong academic background, which has always been a leveller for me amongst my c-suite peers.

Steve Carpenter: I’m biased as I don’t have any CIPD qualifications and have done alright. I’m an accidental HR professional who started life in hospitality and retail operations. This meant that I was able to bring a different perspective which was well-received in the organisations that I worked in. If I didn’t have this aspect, then I wouldn’t have been successful. However, it was a hard slog at times, especially when there were obvious gaps in my technical knowledge. I think there is downside to being too purist in HR, which can be a risk if all knowledge is through something academic like the CIPD. In summary – I don’t think that qualifications are necessary, but I also don’t think they are a bad thing. Ultimately it comes down to how knowledge and experience is applied. And, as importantly, your attitude!

2: How much do you think the promotion of ‘accidental managers’ (who receive no leadership training) contributes to the lack of engagement and performance we see in poor cultures?

Amanda Rajkumar: Yes of course this is part of the problem – but the other part falls on the accountablity of the direct line managers or these newly appointed managers, who put them into these roles without the requsite level of training. development or coaching.

Steve Carpenter: In my experience – lots! – I think there are three causes of this: 1. The lack of leadership/people management training, 2. The selection of people who might not want to take on the people management responsibilities (but want the promotion), 3. The lack of positive role models, which I believe has a bigger impact than lack of training. A desire to want to be a good people manager is the most important element – finding out how is a lot easier if the desire is there.

Jordan Barry-Bayliss: This is a huge problem and why the best organisations test the emotional intelligence (and IQ) of anyone who leads people. The first thing I do in any organisation that requires an uplift in culture and performance, is to transform the capability of front line and middle managers (often pivoting their roles to become more coaching focused whilst honing their behavioural and communication skills).

3: Our profession talks about being people centric but actions lean more towards the executive and leadership and the apparent good of the business. How we execute some of our work – for example making redundancies, is where we must be the advocates for human centred practice. My question is – when did it become part of HR’s role to screw people over on redundancy settlements? Let’s be honest – there’s a difference between fiscally driven decisions and blatantly disadvantaging someone. Or put another way – making people redundant in December – putting them in the job market in the worst month of the year?

Steve Carpenter: This feels like this question has perhaps been driven by a specific and quite painful incident. If HR is playing a strategic role in the business and is involved at the start of conversations like these, then HR has a responsibility to speak up and fight for what it believes is right for all three parts of the organisation (the shareholders, the customers and the employees in equal measure). By doing so, HR can influence the right approach in these difficult situations (provided they have established themselves appropriately). If HR isn’t in a strategic position and is just on the receiving end of instructions from leadership, this of course, is more difficult to do. The next question is, what if HR isn’t in a strategic role? This is clearly a more difficult challenge, but one worth working towards for the good of the organisation. It will be that some organisations won’t accept HR in this way (this perhaps is a time to question what you want to be in HR). From experience, most companies do appreciate strategic input form HR once they can see its value. I think it’s as much HR’s job to make this value visible to leadership as it is theirs to see it. It’s not easy – but it’s doable and well worth the effort.

Jordan Barry-Bayliss: In my experience, there is a direct correlation between the competence and performance of the HR function with the overall competence and performance of the actual organisation. My counsel would be to assess the following before considering whether the business and HR function is right for you.

– The credibility and reputation of the CPO.

– Whether or not the CPO reports directly into the CEO, alongside an understanding of the quality of their relationship.

– If it’s a strategic HR turnaround, make sure the CEO has a genuine commitment to the people and culture agenda, otherwise avoid it at all costs.

– The quality of the recruitment process, including the gravitas of those who’ve interviewed you.

– Ask to meet some of the other people in the HR team, to make your own assessment of their competence.

– Ask “What do people get fired for here?” That’s usually a good indication of the reality of the organisation’s culture and what’s important to its leaders.

If HR are being asked to fire people before Christmas and have no influence to change that, then it’s clearly not an organisation that values its people or HR function.




Latest Events

Apr 2024 – Reward and Recognition – is that the best you can do?

Delve into standard and innovative ways HR can effectively reward and recognise employees from the start!
Reward and recognition HR Webinar from The HR World

May 2024 – Equality, Diversity, Inclusion: Put your money where your mouth is

Is EDI still a vital part of every business' agenda and what good does it deliver for HR?
May 2024 Webinar from the HR World

May 2024 – Employee Benefits: How to Stop Wasting Money

Are you throwing money at employee benefits or a health and wellbeing programme that aren't appreciated?

Mar 2024 – Leveraging Digital Learning Tools: Empowering HR Teams for Success

In today's fast-paced business landscape, the role of HR teams is evolving rapidly. To stay competitive and foster organisational growth, companies must leverage effective learning programs strategically.

Mar 2024 – The Efficiency Programme: How HR can maximise technology benefits

There are huge promises and potential for the use of AI and technology in HR and in this session we discuss the best way ahead for HR for technology and AI use.

Effective Resourcing Models & How We Guarantee the Integrity of Inclusive Recruitment Regardless of Approach

A opportunity to debate how can we adopt a cohesive inclusive approach that enhances the candidate experience without creating barriers between us and the talent essential to your organisational success.

Feb 2024 – It’s All HR’s Fault

Despite being a trusted voice in the C-suite, HR is still viewed with distrust and outright disdain by many employees – the very people HR is there to support.
Its all HRs Fault On demand Webinar

Jan 2024 – Health and Wellbeing: Making it Personal

If you’re investing in a health and wellbeing strategy, you want to make sure it meets the needs of your workforce.

Dec 2023 – Year in Review 2023

In this webinar we brought back some of our previous 2023 webinar speakers who gave their view on the past 12 months.

Nov 2023 – Reward and Recognition for the International Workforce

In this webinar we explored the dispersed workplace and asked what it means to support employees all over the world.
Reward and Recognition for the International Workforce

Streamlining Year-End HR Operations

Providing seasonal support, ideas and inspiration, this webinar covered the challenges and opportunities presented to HR professionals at this time of year.
Streamlining year-end HR operations

Compensation Planning – The key to a motivated and satisfied workforce

Compensation and reward strategies have changed radically over the past few years with the impact of the pandemic and the trends that followed.
Compensation Planning - The key to a motivated and satisfied workforce

Oct 2023 – Talent Acquisition: Why your Employee Value Proposition (EVP) is more important than ever

This webinar addressing talent acquisition majored on the Employee Value Proposition (EVP).
Talent Acquisition – Why your Employee Value Proposition (EVP) is more important than ever

Resourcing Models, Insource, Outsource or Hybrid what are the best solutions?

Discussions on the evening were led by two invited experts Jim Richardson, with spells at Santander and Royal Bank of Scotland as Global Head of Talent, Jim now advises corporate businesses on their TA models, and, Ross Crook, Managing Director at Sanderson Solutions.
Resourcing models round table

Sep 2023 – Retention: Holding on to The Talent You Need

The post-pandemic workforce now presents more of a challenge in terms of feeling satisfied and content in the workplace. This webinar on retention also provided a masterclass on employee engagement.
Retention holding on to the talent you need

Aug 2023 – Professional Development: Making the Step Up

What does it take to be an HR Director, or to take a position at Board level? This webinar looked at professional development for HR leaders.
What does it take to be an HR Director?

Jul 2023 – Employee Benefits: Then, now and next

The importance and value of giving employees choice on rewards and recognition.
Employee benefits, then now and next.

Jun 2023 – HR Data: The Key To Delivering Real Value

This webinar on HR Data brought home the importance of understanding the value of people data not just to HR but to the business as a whole.
HR on demand event - HR data: the key to delivering real value

RPO Market – Insource, Outsource or Hybrid: What are the best solutions?

The HR World and Sanderson Managed Services Ltd held an exclusive Round Table dinner to explore and debate the current RPO arena.

AI as part of the hiring, on-boarding and retention processes

The HR World and Sanderson Managed Services Ltd held an exclusive Round Table dinner to further the discussion of AI among Senior HR Leaders.

May 2023 – AI in HR: The Perfect Balance

AI is hitting the headlines right now as experts forecast a future that’s powered by tech. But what will this mean for HR?
On demand hr webinar - Ai in HR

Apr 2023 – HR Tech: Ensuring your technology delivers for all your people

Technology continues to throw challenges at the HR function as the speed of change increases and new technology (anyone noticed something called AI?) enters the arena.
HR tech on demand webinar with Sympa

Mar 2023 – Equality, diversity, and inclusion: Reshaping thinking for action

In this webinar we explored how ED&I can have a real impact for businesses. At the centre of the discussion was the idea of changing thinking in order to make things happen.
Equality, diversity, and inclusion: Reshaping thinking for action

Feb 2023 – Leading With Agility: How to give your business the behaviours and mindsets it needs for volatile times

This webinar took as its focus agility and how businesses can develop and maintain these skills among its workforce.
This webinar took as its focus agility and how businesses can develop and maintain these skills among its workforce.

Jan 2023 – How can you create a culture of health and wellbeing in the workplace?

This webinar tackled the important and timely issue of creating a health and wellbeing culture in the workplace.
How can you create a culture of health and wellbeing in the workplace?

Hiring Gen Z – what can employers learn about emerging talent in 2023?

Join us at this cross-learning, in-person event as part of The HR World Culture Clash series at RSA House in London on 20 Oct 2022.
Hiring Gen Z: Culture Clash Panellists

Bridging the gap: what can employers learn about emerging talent to drive better hiring strategies?

Join us at this cross-learning, in-person event as part of The HR World Culture Clash series, bringing HRDs, founders and emerging talent together to build a better workforce for the future.
Bridging the gap: what can employers learn about emerging talent to drive better hiring strategies?
HRW Membership@2x@2x

Are you a senior HR professional?

Join our membership to shape the future of work, get exclusive access to events, white papers and research content, profile your work, gain access to support from HR experts and celebrate your successes.

Become a Partner

Please get in touch to talk about how we can help your business make an impact in the world of work through our content marketing, partnership plans and advertising.