Home » Knowledge Hub » » Legal Speak – the dimensions of private workplace conversations

Legal Speak – the dimensions of private workplace conversations

30 October 2023

An illustration of dialogue and thoughts taking place among silhouettes of people in various positions.  The speech bubbles are yellow, pink, light blue, red and green.  The sole thought bubble is purple.  The bubbles are of varying sizes and shapes.  For example, the yellow one resembles a flag on a short flagpole, while the blue one resembles a round pin.  Some of the silhouetted people are touching their hands to their chins, and one is gesturing upward with his pointer finger.  Some of the silhouettes have their heads tilted slightly forward.

In light of  the David Walliams data breach case, Lorna Shuttleworth, Employment Solicitor, and Danielle Amor, Commercial Director at law firm Pannone Corporate, discuss what insights can be gleaned when confidential discussions enter the realm of public opinion.

In November 2022, longtime judge of Britain’s Got Talent, David Walliams, admitted to making “disrespectful comments” about two unsuccessful contestants, who appeared on the show more than two year earlier. The comments were reported in the Guardian, which claimed to have seen a “leaked transcript” of the remarks. Walliams left the show shortly after, following 10 years on the judging panel. At the time, he apologised for the comments saying, “These were private conversations and – like most conversations with friends – were never intended to be shared. Nevertheless, I am sorry.”

The dust appeared to have settled but, fast-forward nearly 12 months, Walliams has now filed a multi-million pound claim against the Britain’s Got Talent production company, Fremantle. Walliams is reportedly claiming that he is entitled to compensation for lost earnings and lost future earnings as a result of Fremantle’s data breach which seriously affected his mental health.

Walliams is clearly disgruntled that his comments were published and feels his reputation and livelihood have been tarnished as a result. However, he has limited options in terms of a legal claim against Fremantle. The leaked comments were not defamatory of him (he made them himself); he was not a Fremantle employee; and there is unlikely to have been a breach of contract.

Fremantle (or someone in its production crew) perhaps felt justified in disclosing that Walliams was not necessarily the “national treasure” character he portrays on screen. However, in the employment context, it can be very tricky managing a situation where information comes to light that causes you to see an employee differently. So what should you do?

  • Set the standards early on. Whilst the David Walliams case is exceptional, many employers face the issue of discovering conversations between colleagues which are not appropriate for the workplace. In the most extreme cases, derogatory comments made by one employee about another could result in a claim for harassment. The employer will be liable unless it can show it took all reasonable steps to prevent the conduct taking place. One such step is educating employees on what is and isn’t acceptable in the workplace via policies and training, with managers reinforcing a culture where expectations are clear. Employees need to be aware that their conversations at work are not guaranteed to be private – even if they are speaking with a colleague in a WhatsApp chat, those messages may be disclosable in certain circumstances.
  • Consider how the information has been obtained. As an employer, you should not be “snooping” on your employees by checking their social media or monitoring their emails. Unless the information has been lawfully obtained, you should be very wary about taking action.
  • Is the information true? Making statements to a third party of information which is not true could lead to a claim for defamation. Check the veracity of the conversation before disclosing it to anyone else.
  • Comply with the GDPR. Assuming the information is true and would lead you to think differently of an employee, consider whether you can use that information to take action in accordance with the GDPR. For example, “criminal offence data” under the GDPR is subject to stricter requirements than ordinary personal data and you need additional justification to process that data.
  • Consider your employees’ wellbeing. Even if you are entitled to take action, consider how your actions will impact on the wellbeing of the employee concerned and the wider staff team. These matters should be handled sensitively to avoid negatively impacting individuals’ mental health.

In the “cancel culture” era, it is difficult to know where to draw the line. Public backlash can arise and you risk upsetting your workforce where action is taken or not taken, or taken too quickly or too slowly! Spent convictions and decade-old posts on social media clearly have to be put to one side, but it is so easy for a person’s private life to seep into the professional sphere and damage their professional reputation as well as future employment opportunities.

Walliams is a household name, so perhaps held to a higher standard than most; however, over the last few months we have seen senior figures step down from the likes of NatWest, BP, the CBI, the Pennine Care NHS Trust, UK Athletics and Tesco to name a few, over behaviour or comments seen as conflicting with their professional roles. Often, once the information is made public, events take over and the outcome is determined by the court of public opinion. As such, individuals need to be aware that ‘private’ conversations at work may not always remain private.




Latest Events

Reward and Recognition for the International Workforce

In this webinar we explored the dispersed workplace and asked what it means to support employees all over the world.
Reward and Recognition for the International Workforce

Year in Review 2023

In this specially extended webinar we bring back some of our previous 2023 webinar speakers to give their view on the past 12 months and gaze into the collective crystal ball of 2024.

Resourcing Models, Insource, Outsource or Hybrid what are the best solutions?

Discussions on the evening will be led by two invited experts Jim Richardson, with spells at Santander and Royal Bank of Scotland as Global Head of Talent, Jim now advises corporate businesses on their TA models. And, Ross Crook, Managing Director at Sanderson Solutions.
Resourcing models round table

Retention: Holding on to The Talent You Need

In September we explored retention in the workplace.
HR Webinar - Retention

Professional Development: Making the Step Up

The HR World’s webinar this month took a long hard look at professional development for HR leaders.

Employee Benefits: Then, now and next

In July as we delved into the world of employee benefits.
HR Webinar - the HR benefits.

AI in HR: The Perfect Balance

AI is hitting the headlines right now as experts forecast a future that’s powered by tech. But what will this mean for HR?
On demand hr webinar - Ai in HR

RPO Market: Insource, Outsource or Hybrid – What are the best solutions?

The HR World and Sanderson Managed Services Ltd are holding an exclusive Round Table dinner to explore and debate the current RPO arena.

AI as part of the hiring, on-boarding and retention processes

The HR World and Sanderson Managed Services Ltd are holding an exclusive Round Table dinner to further the discussion of AI among Senior HR Leaders.

Equality, diversity, and inclusion: Reshaping thinking for action

Join us in March as our monthly webinar tackles equality, diversity, and inclusion in the workplace.

Leading With Agility: How to give your business the behaviours and mindsets it needs for volatile times

Join us in February as our monthly webinar tackles learning and development in the workplace.

How can you create a culture of health and wellbeing in the workplace?

Our January webinar tackled health and wellbeing in the workplace.

The role of HR in reputation management

The recent P&O mass firings have yet again highlighted the critical role HR plays in managing a business' reputational risks - and how it can go horribly wrong.
Event with Anna Elliott The role of HR in reputation management

The metaverse and HR

The HR World with future of work experts Lloyd Dean and Alexander Low, from PA Consulting, will cut through the chaos and stay clear of the jargon in this 45-minute webinar to help HRs navigate the metaverse.

Hiring Gen Z – what can employers learn about emerging talent in 2023?

Join us at this cross-learning, in-person event as part of The HR World Culture Clash series at RSA House in London on 20 Oct 2022.
Hiring Gen Z: Culture Clash Panellists

Bridging the gap: what can employers learn about emerging talent to drive better hiring strategies?

Join us at this cross-learning, in-person event as part of The HR World Culture Clash series, bringing HRDs, founders and emerging talent together to build a better workforce for the future.
Bridging the gap: what can employers learn about emerging talent to drive better hiring strategies?

How to put inclusivity at the heart of your job description process

‘Diversity’ and ‘inclusion’ – are these words used so often in talent attraction strategies they have almost become meaningless?
The Job Design Revolution

Supporting your people through loss and change – with Julie Stokes OBE

Loss. We have all experienced it, individually, in our communities and in our business lives. How can we lead our people in an ever-changing environment?
Webinar supporting your people through loss and change
HRW Membership@2x@2x

Are you a senior HR professional?

Join our membership to shape the future of work, get exclusive access to events, white papers and research content, profile your work, gain access to support from HR experts and celebrate your successes.

Become a Partner

Please get in touch to talk about how we can help your business make an impact in the world of work through our content marketing, partnership plans and advertising.